New online community study: what’s working, what’s in the way, advice from trenches

Written by Lois Kelly on July 16, 2008 – 9:00 am -

Today my firm, Beeline Labs, Deloitte, and the Society for New Communications Research released highlights of an online communities study among 140 organizations which create and maintain communities. Some of the highlights, more of which can be found here:

Greatest value of communities:

  • increasing word of mouth (35%)
  • increasing brand awareness (28%)
  • bringing new ideas into the organization faster (24%)
  • increasing customer loyalty (24%)

Greatest obstacles

  • getting people involved in the community (51%)
  • finding enough time to manage the community (45%)
  • attracting people to the community (34%)

What contributes most to effectiveness:

• ability for community members to connect with other like-minded people: 54%
• ability for members to help others: 43%
• focusing community  around a hot topic or issue: 41%
• quality of the community manager/community management team: 33%

Advice for others

When asked what their most important piece of advice is for others creating communities, survey participants’ advice focused around these eight areas:

1.    Start with the end in mind: “Start with a business strategy, defining carefully what you want to accomplish through the community.”

2.    Focus on the value to the members:  “Make sure you deliver real, special, unique, obvious value to the core group you’re hoping to attract.”

3.    Don’t start with the technology: “Too often people get drunk with Web 2.0 tool excitement and then try to push their business and customer goals into the wrong tool.”

4.    Keep it simple and intuitive:  “Focus on the least common denominator first. Keep it easy to navigate with simple tools to use.”

5.    Keep it fresh and active:  “Keep activity levels up, constantly add new content.”

6.    Have dynamic community leaders: “Make sure you devote enough time to managing the community; letting it fester is worse than not having it in the first place.”

7.    Think through who to involve – or not. “Get Legal and PR to buy-in and help on design, but keep them out of active management.”

8.    Get a passionate core of participants active before launching:  “Make sure you have a committed core of passionate users before you launch.”
Many thanks to everyone who took the time to take the survey and talk to us as part of the qualitative surveys. The complete results are on their way to you this morning.


Posted in Marketing 2.0, Tribalization of Business |

Leave a Comment

New + Notable:

Check out our new resources section for the 2008 Tribalization of Business study. The section includes: all the charts and graphs from the research, available for use on your blog or report; access to all the coverage of the study; a recording of our July 31st webinar that includes the slides; graphics and buttons from the report and more.

Check it out here.


  • News & Views

    • Beeline Partner Lois Kelly contributed an essay to the just-published second edition of

      Find out more and buy The Age of Conversation 2 here

    • Mobile Messaging 2.0 Thought Leadership Community wins the Society of New Communications Research's award of Merit (click here for more)
  • Also Catch Us At




  • Interesting projects we are working on

    • Survey research study with Deloitte and SNCR on how companies measure their communities (stay tuned)